click here to tweet this post
click here to share with your friends
subscribe to this feed
click here to format for printing
Book Review: Retreiving Doctrine (by Jonathan Dorst)
by C. Michael PattonApril 4th, 2011
In the recent movie Leaves of Grass, there is a scene with twin brothers, one a Classics professor at Brown University, the other a pot dealer in Oklahoma. The dealer tells his brother, “I read a article you wrote… about a fella called Heidegger… what I don’t understand about ya’ll… ya’ll hardly ever write about a topic. I mean, you write about what some other fella wrote about the topic… and some other fella’s gonna come along and on and on.” At which point the professor brother reluctantly admits, “You’ve very neatly explained academia.”
This review would fall under that description- reviewing what someone wrote about what somebody else said. And for that, I can understand how some would find this whole enterprise irrelevant. Nevertheless, having conversations in print with some of the finest theological minds in history is something I find not only interesting, but worth time and effort.
Retrieving Doctrine: Essays in Reformed Theology purports to be an exercise in theological dialogue “in the spirit of collegiality.” The authors with whom Dr. Oliver Crisp interacts are all long-gone, but their writings still influence Reformed thinkers and churches today. Dr. Crisp, for his part, is conversant with both modern and classical theologians and seeks to understand the historical context of the ancients while addressing their contribution, or quarrel, with modern theology. Crisp is logical and precise (for instance using the term ‘Calvinian’ when referring directly to Calvin’s theological writing and ‘Calvinist’ when speaking of the tradition) and therefore a helpful guide to some dense thinkers. The best praise I can give him is that he made me want to read the original sources more, which I suppose was his aim all along. Continue Reading »

















